One thing I wish we could do but can't now with Oakland right behind us in the wild card race, is have Sevy skip a start or at least give him extra days of rest between starts. We need his slider to be sharp again.
I think I would start Sheff, and give everybody else in the staff an extra day's rest.
McCutch has been clutch recently. Gardy with his calf muscle injury needs rest to heal up, so I would start McCutchen in left when Judge comes back.